How do you write a replication paper?

How do you write a replication paper?

In a replication paper, the author should try to provide independent evidence for or against the conclusions of a published paper. The purpose of a replication paper should not be to introduce new ideas or explanations, but should only focus on providing more evidence for or against the previous conclusions.

Are replication studies published?

Hence, replication studies are carried out and published very rarely as compared to original studies. Since replication studies are considered an important aspect of scientific progress, some researchers think that the general outlook toward them should change.

What is replication in economics?

The Sad State of Scientific Replication in Economics Most of what economists view as replication represents scientific replication—re- examining an idea in some published research by studying it using a different data set chosen from a different population from that used in the original paper.

Is a replicated study valid?

When studies are replicated and achieve the same or similar results as the original study, it gives greater validity to the findings. If a researcher can replicate a study’s results, it means that it is more likely that those results can be generalized to the larger population.

What is the purpose of replicating a study?

A replication study attempts to validate the findings of a prior piece of research. By doing so, that prior research is confirmed as being both accurate and broadly applicable, since the replication study typically changes one or more variables of the original study, such as sample population, industry sector, etc.

Do you need permission to replicate a study?

If you are able to replicate a study for your dissertation, remember that you are required to get permission to use the instrument from the original creator of the dissertation. You must also obtain permission to use any modified instruments if those were employed in the study.

Where can I publish replication studies?

To support such ventures, we are launching ReScienceX, a free-to-publish and free-to-read, peer-reviewed journal that will be devoted to reproduction and replication experiments. Research students and early-career researchers should be given credit for publishing replication studies.

Are null results published?

Elegant on paper due to its simplicity, the process is complicated by the fact that null results often don’t get published, which may doom different research efforts into gathering the same data over and over again.

How do you title a replicated paper?

Give your project a descriptive title that describes the effect of interest, that it is a replication, and what study is being replicated (e.g. Replication of Gervais & Norenzayan (2012) – Analytic Thinking Promotes Religious Disbellief).

Why do we repeat experiments 3 times?

Repeating an experiment more than once helps determine if the data was a fluke, or represents the normal case. It helps guard against jumping to conclusions without enough evidence. The number of repeats depends on many factors, including the spread of the data and the availability of resources.

Why research can be replicated?

It is very important that research can be replicated, because it means that other researchers can test the findings of the research. Replicability keeps researchers honest and can give readers confidence in research.

What is the origin of replication in eukaryotes?

The origin of replication successively binds the origin recognition complex (ORC) and the Cdc6 protein. Together with Cdt1, these then recruit two MCM helicase complexes. This forms the pre-replicative complex (pre-RC). The origin recognition complex recognizes the origins of eukaryotic chromosomes.

How is DNA replication controlled by the origin recognition complex?

“DNA replication control through interaction of E2F-RB and the origin recognition complex”. Nature Cell Biology. 3 (3): 289–95. doi: 10.1038/35060086. PMID 11231579. S2CID 24942902. ^ Chuang RY, Kelly TJ (March 1999). “The fission yeast homologue of Orc4p binds to replication origin DNA via multiple AT-hooks”.

Are site-specific DNA replication origins necessary for genome duplication?

Although DNA replication is essential for genetic inheritance, defined, site-specific replication origins are technically not a requirement for genome duplication as long as all chromosomes are copied in their entirety to maintain gene copy numbers.

What is the replicon hypothesis of DNA replication?

A fundamental feature of the replicon hypothesis is that it relies on positive regulation to control DNA replication onset, which can explain many experimental observations in bacterial and phage systems. For example, it accounts for the failure of extrachromosomal DNAs without origins to replicate when introduced into host cells.